{"article_id":"4741","schema_version":2,"source_content_hash":"13cd0aa3433901197891f1b6b20a2ae26835fafca3a4bfdb1635518a87bc45b2","computed_at":"2026-08-24T06:42:43Z","payload":{"topic":{"subtopic":"Может ли группа глупцов породить умную мысль","canonical":"Коллективный интеллект против индивидуальной мудрости","confidence":0.95,"related_topics":["Мудрость толпы","Принятие решений большинством голосов","Социальная психология"]},"entities":[{"role":"primary","type":"other","canonical_name":"коллективный разум"},{"role":"primary","type":"other","canonical_name":"голосование"},{"role":"secondary","type":"other","canonical_name":"большинство"},{"role":"secondary","type":"other","canonical_name":"закон математики"}],"passages":[{"kind":"definition","text":"Ключевой вопрос статьи — способна ли тысяча глупцов, собравшись вместе, породить хоть одну умную мысль."},{"kind":"comparison","text":"Друг считает, что коллективный разум мудрее, поэтому большинство может родить мудрость."},{"kind":"comparison","text":"Автор возражает: закон математики говорит, что сложение нулей даёт ноль, а толпа выберет не лучшего, а того, кто громче орёт."},{"kind":"answer","text":"Окончательного вывода в статье нет: автор обращается к читателям с вопросом, на чьей они стороне."}],"faq_items":[{"answer":"В тексте нет однозначного вывода. Друг утверждает, что коллективный разум мудрее; автор контраргументирует, что сложение нулей даёт ноль и большинство выберет громкого, а не лучшего.","question":"Может ли тысяча глупцов родить умную мысль?","confidence":0.97}],"seo_title":"Может ли коллективный разум быть мудрее? Спор о голосовании и «сумме нулей»","ai_summary":"Автор рассказывает о споре с другом о голосовании и коллективном разуме: может ли тысяча глупцов, собравшись вместе, породить умную мысль. Друг отвечает утвердительно, автор возражает, что сумма нулей равна нулю и толпа выберет не лучшего, а самого громкого.","meaning_text":"Центральная мысль — призыв усомниться в «мудрости толпы»: простое суммирование мнений не гарантирует истину, а голосование может выдвинуть не лучшего, а самого заметного и громкого.","subject_text":"Статья — это личное рассуждение о доверии к коллективному мнению: может ли большое количество обычных людей совместно прийти к умной идее, если каждый по отдельности ничего выдающегося не представляет.","key_takeaways":["Статья построена вокруг спора: способна ли тысяча глупцов родить умную мысль.","Друг защищает идею, что коллективный разум мудрее.","Автор сомневается, ссылаясь на принцип «сложение нулей даёт ноль».","По мнению автора, при голосовании толпа может выбрать не лучшего, а самого громкого.","Итог не подводится: вопрос выносят на обсуждение читателей."],"author_profile":{"bio":"Международное PR агентство PR.help","content_centroid":[-0.03265255,-0.011645607,-0.007624806,0.032490045,-0.018345488,0.01657341,-0.028371938,-0.022501115,0.017674414,0.023519646,0.036735788,-0.0031049983,-0.035594985,0.0175221,-0.016191987,-0.048023835,0.03765808,0.014393722,-0.033414863,-0.030627409,0.012225117,0.011355191,-0.03756706,-0.046424307,-0.018894533,-0.0354296,-0.030852653,0.023962362,0.020825936,0.008374177,0.017161053,-0.014873307,-0.00093013165,-0.058803298,0.0024593396,0.014432972,-0.02541978,-0.014540054,-0.001514277,0.029393695,0.021062218,0.018163051,-0.009922708,-0.041262884,-0.0001700315,-0.04254239,-0.031870883,-0.044570208,-0.038785163,-0.016901577,0.013956588,-0.002045164,-0.007823544,-0.043151062,0.014077419,0.013385823,-0.02813582,0.03806572,-0.016160715,0.019181166,-0.023025963,-0.025800876,-0.033181604,0.028530281,0.035425186,0.060832206,-0.03117352,-0.016054315,-0.011665735,-0.0031952292,0.046054684,-0.04296382,-0.020141331,0.0070329146,0.011593083,-0.00413672,0.047756102,0.019453062,0.009557428,-0.042513993,0.01741885,0.0067995624,-0.012809158,-0.05065685,-0.07331542,0.04376536,-0.0289865,0.040808063,-0.0213234,0.024536494,0.01158457,0.012052373,0.06124402,0.01702763,-0.012279833,0.02261048,0.011875526,0.028963776,0.00568906,0.037939183,-0.018531518,-0.00035454048,-0.025499338,0.042331215,-0.0024549968,-0.016363405,0.011179494,0.0069983914,-0.019550847,0.001309017,-0.016299058,-0.0350715,-0.06497523,0.013396631,0.009696492,-0.0738054,-0.0058909557,0.0009269783,-0.024485005,-0.019438606,-0.008929093,-0.025776962,0.015815677,-0.020805161,-0.02952932,-0.059000336,-0.03173307,0.07086088,-0.000787962,0.03987091,0.017026717,0.047757078,-0.0015108039,-0.0108632,-0.029179005,0.037226785,0.003835862,0.014856106,0.026157439,0.068611175,0.009207994,-0.014980523,-0.028678225,0.04069303,0.025349157,0.040850084,0.0103539815,0.0066305753,-0.027575092,0.00687816,-0.009245444,-0.0087250415,-0.08451665,-0.022293625,0.024140865,0.034859758,-0.016569603,-0.020889254,-0.03299928,0.045446374,-0.04940527,0.0026476583,-0.032514248,-0.012953559,0.03586549,0.0032846085,0.03783025,-0.00065323,-0.037962846,-0.022897702,-0.019734204,-0.021798767,0.04421587,0.0325916,0.02301828,-0.0048638196,-0.0009875825,0.015394188,0.07646199,-0.0003561794,0.0120589165,-0.017741507,-0.043328878,0.021356804,0.007090063,0.05880055,-0.005852988,-0.028916981,0.0043183276,-0.00055684603,-0.011831418,0.021085307,-0.031122273,-0.0281093,-0.028122438,0.0012647772,0.0030429212,-0.011683585,-0.0018735022,-0.014466685,-0.044392902,0.007783151,0.01431408,0.02812274,-0.00921372,0.00018788759,0.073947094,0.056066994,-0.0098130815,-0.0005757497,-0.025551725,0.049554117,0.023780635,0.010405971,-0.019460574,-0.020147894,0.006164902,-0.05714841,0.07281541,-0.0051300707,-0.075601734,-0.0030154968,-0.013907612,-0.013468768,-0.044182725,-0.03125228,-0.045715585,-0.009220984,0.0106153665,0.009129611,-0.012258001,-0.009374556,0.054537755,-0.0029377842,-0.068740845,-0.010386106,-0.017686361,-0.03959407,-0.03480098,0.05031361,0.03672501,-0.011777368,0.0285177,0.031637996,0.040843643,-0.0054486985,-0.0078958245,0.008119129,-0.008298577,-0.06764444,0.012091418,0.056225225,0.00083809963,0.05153751,0.005662291,0.0126720555,0.0023558356,0.013454292,0.018716156,0.014401528,-0.04874489,-0.030401943,-0.028729685,0.07022817,-0.019182509,0.040276054,-0.014552787,-0.013040497,-0.011355138,0.041707616,0.0005913065,-0.03137911,-0.014386587,0.038935985,0.01770053,0.07102323,-0.020950282,-0.010785942,-0.0006650708,-0.03340507,0.03943711,0.035739664,0.040646255,0.010416574,-0.011521617,0.04589154,-0.0025247196,-0.017831672,0.029872682,0.04502787,-0.0014488191,-0.0011332603,-0.02269428,-0.04079231,0.0007393125,-0.026056211,-0.02246135,0.026530351,0.02574759,0.048281886,-0.030610813,0.0050810482,-0.007955612,-0.02096221,0.0046604564,0.010082299,-0.05491492,-0.002659705,0.003016867,0.013518341,0.0032998913,0.02200001,0.025541741,0.02563545,0.036500715,-0.036584653,0.0071536507,0.012956166,-0.012538728,-0.057443034,-0.010240009,-0.06481054,0.0029736273,-0.02835632,0.000060327555,0.026134642,-0.009702289,-0.03575948,-0.024804043,0.009870911,0.0048085563,-0.0003527252,-0.039684866,-0.046785615,0.022267919,-0.043023974,-0.026349284,-0.030273277,-0.0067048245,-0.023916494,-0.010525755,0.040087305,0.027278755,0.024097,0.019482525,0.057826214,0.0063780653,0.044815335,-0.00049120706,-0.024376735,-0.010503952,0.01236263,-0.043138504,-0.015080456,-0.025341624,-0.06180472,0.0152379675,-0.019991042,-0.028469233,0.017757028,-0.035033055,-0.0127151,-0.026137263,-0.049073994,-0.0018474892,0.0555088,-0.015667124,-0.010709296,0.07694041,0.011268058,0.0065860497,0.028117917,-0.0020508843,0.0050794655,-0.014837531,-0.0424538,0.0090812445,0.01351735,-0.027403018,0.0050981836,-0.0016392884,0.024750639,-0.032612357,-0.016832517,-0.051109385,0.009895586,-0.029079264,-0.010553835,0.0018716883,-0.022382015,0.00016616035,-0.048400532,0.01767154,0.054423455,-0.013150216,0.0065867957,-0.015954792,-0.009830652,0.014662537,0.009075943,0.03420995,-0.042395145,-0.019971753,0.032195475,0.047396112,0.0067113843,0.03117121,-0.031612985,-0.013987742,-0.05377106,0.020070061,-0.03392673,-0.04406794,-0.020792602,0.02681787,0.02447992,0.008181547,0.010468319,0.007885613,-0.027371801,-0.0124936225,0.011295798,0.06104204,0.05375193,0.035651248,-0.04691318,-0.04964154,0.008656629,0.006188417,-0.009900754,-0.027716467,0.005115229,0.039130636,0.05324948,-0.01892791,0.0074947192,0.011970377,-0.005967896,-0.023798479,0.00856277,0.06827932,-0.024671908,-0.015023718,-0.04512071,0.0023824724,0.02385307,-0.008822006,-0.030153492,0.014002675,0.06598013,0.00943229,0.064593524,-0.00022095435,0.04918984,-0.022024492,0.031982496,-0.00084426126,-0.03220562,-0.01838441,-0.023113163,0.0003398966,0.04543555,0.008645563,0.006626823,0.063518375,0.0013655721,-0.0015568893,-0.01152128,0.02086027,-0.050238416,0.045229204,-0.02316792,0.0027453555,0.036738344,-0.021238448,0.03475173,0.018627604,-0.011310162,-0.01516767,0.018704781,0.012899433,-0.04566183,-0.037018165,-0.08980755,-0.039287534,0.014255499,-0.035460826,0.037470225,-0.020130413,-0.012337519,-0.033724893,0.027455157,0.014137883,-0.029631509,0.0056855204,0.02838778,-0.03445587,0.010470365,0.010527362,0.00030840514,0.005949795,-0.0224317,-0.038540315,0.0069011087,-0.021017404,-0.04010158,0.027246505,0.02967039,0.0017785351,0.018848572,-0.0141405575,0.00882943,0.02579545,-0.02567697,-0.043803167,-0.022433927,0.042116266,-0.017596615,0.014338491,-0.036885217,-0.021976994,0.022924839,-0.02110652,-0.029433358,0.028975796,-0.035174057,0.07365834,0.05598988,-0.024444876,-0.08547289,-0.031197296,-0.010903242,-0.03002472,0.009220486,0.0018902632,0.058349606,-0.013855956,-0.0063272635,0.018022167,0.035456106,0.047617886,-0.016896825,-0.014214434,-0.00023666034,-0.00905523,0.020895045,0.0058580195,0.06545115,0.03615111,0.010106411,-0.035442315,-0.010694238,0.034492448,-0.0088087525,-0.0069109015,-0.027354889,0.052404087,0.059933744,-0.040783394,0.013248907,0.015875155,-0.0019510039,0.0033465344,-0.047340013,0.034331266,-0.07002473,0.04058972,0.0014594155,0.04338128,-0.005299724,-0.03597408,-0.037313513,-0.014929783,0.018069912,0.03346268,-0.061771125,0.04094105,0.0025578253,0.012334109,-0.0018138799,0.026191637,0.016974503,0.016530167,-0.006813617,-0.01057118,-0.040021583,0.0029187093,0.0025664526,-0.00444149,0.015082867,-0.017609453,0.034230538,-0.02596339,0.027325006,-0.007733861,0.06953986,-0.062334474,0.009596381,0.02995383,0.031536985,-0.029950269,0.0053097378,-0.020797277,0.019007122,0.036127146,0.007790542,0.08704555,-0.03908322,-0.046507493,0.0037719226,-0.013110313,0.03446197,0.025698973,0.044235952,0.001920305,0.006765171,-0.048344355,-0.046883605,-0.023822369,-0.019234499,-0.0045199296,-0.012631707,-0.009247229,-0.013964354,-0.091595165,-0.058685888,-0.039688,0.028255356,-0.01682201,0.016071133,-0.016644275,0.017719368,-0.039805375,0.02009887,0.0031850573,-0.051954348,0.0049557937,0.052132268,0.014605119,-0.0009281107,-0.0049515483,0.07644514,-0.0026639034,0.01247649,0.0030246929,-0.035794917,-0.037251774,-0.026514763,-0.0386411,0.02345227,0.05982748,0.053737745,-0.0020377736,0.03745148,0.034421574,0.02781907,-0.021813955,-0.04289634,-0.03290638,0.04695279,-0.0028924998,0.006996979,0.0016003331,-0.068803005,-0.050309736,-0.044646386,0.08443068,-0.033185326,-0.03379845,0.018434912,0.012295406,0.0055457293,-0.010098799,-0.02015238,-0.06874586,-0.05594522,-0.028084554,0.0002490821,-0.025187206,0.0044173487,-0.021360751,0.028365472,-0.05579518,0.021016035,0.049685914,-0.0290262,0.0077550737,0.07246105,0.031219508,0.029739782,0.01594763,0.0018008037,-0.08917001,-0.034275863,-0.03367661,-0.012349186,0.04571855,-0.000926705,-0.02322369,-0.00046849414,-0.022764781,-0.0027924313,-0.010802951,0.015965134,-0.014685255,-0.03549027,-0.040145703,-0.009960642,0.020137787,0.011398127,-0.077550665,-0.05339577,0.030973516,0.041848935,-0.011922002,0.021617763,0.021674953,-0.007692974,0.016449986,0.070192546,-0.028354254,0.033718716,-0.04303259,0.019062907,0.015794832,0.015420496,0.004653265,0.028882483,-0.0056404793,-0.007828389,0.025803193,0.06368519,0.03731065,-0.0009610466,-0.008287462,0.0005340653,-0.03907431,-0.051190622,0.005385787,0.030705446,-0.042511933,-0.018378653,0.012980933,-0.0004742029,-0.027801419,-0.011880723,-0.011451193,0.023914935,-0.03742835,0.04561848,0.04647113,-0.036211684,0.014520905,-0.015650654,-0.07439865,0.097521976,-0.058529872,-0.0035902874,-0.05085618,-0.006951233,0.029692149,-0.0020817067,0.022817872,0.0669558,-0.015142428,-0.04765991,0.02949635,0.004383407,-0.0048001576,-0.024949228,-0.023705611,0.048492562,0.045369137,-0.02795762,-0.008887361,-0.01707906,-0.0070355656,0.0218021,0.02336524,0.05280874,0.025199817,-0.009123065,0.038541485,-0.057231296,0.014398226,-0.026785769,0.024219694,0.061771605,0.026157795,-0.044775728,0.026466552,-0.021939874,-0.000083803345,-0.004296665,0.047761362,-0.022076538,0.010724412,0.00014893123,-0.0046423865,0.07153559,-0.014462695,-0.013743971,0.015152035,0.020814864,0.009435116,0.0570264,-0.0366217,-0.027016299,-0.055066444,0.020425534,-0.06217931,0.012787764,-0.01835607,0.017864546,-0.046702188,0.049661927,-0.005241196,0.0096165845,-0.020573681,0.035022195,-0.026999375,-0.02747001,-0.0017886189,0.07598571,-0.049542412,0.011678921,0.074526,-0.08529699,0.0049463287,0.015571841,-0.02970681,-0.0065138303,0.013267964,0.018545847,-0.0040505133,0.022904227,0.0064455876,0.03411014,0.0077885753,-0.016857024,-0.036508817,0.004873606,0.03278439,-0.005197184,0.022361796,0.030389873,-0.015221609,0.023810623,-0.001780949,-0.04317368,-0.03377891,-0.008486603,-0.05018668,0.029592544,-0.012901512,0.028164348,-0.011811331,-0.02299275,0.027858807,-0.0038992087,0.027889384,0.017074564,-0.010419053,0.005746748,-0.013243377,0.005372032,0.030186782,-0.0592177,0.0050060335,0.057224244,0.060608428,-0.0038717533,0.05469147,0.0064988374,0.0265958,0.03693905,0.025728587,0.0059251096,0.017859418,-0.052860796,0.0024978996,0.027542746,0.041064758,-0.013991021,-0.00031959044,0.03735992,0.008842028,0.005462796,-0.0129811065,-0.010063528,-0.032789815,0.017375702,0.03230681,-0.077944756,-0.051213164,-0.039009966,0.010404204,0.0321148,0.03275349,-0.042695586,0.023696912,0.060908176,-0.028116899,0.00016342256,0.028314982,0.006178095,0.015787968,-0.006312313,-0.027399462,0.03512164,0.044776015,-0.039882537,-0.011556895,0.031308744,0.014768144,-0.034911092,0.011257924,0.020939233,0.018512577,-0.02839495,0.002278648,0.011847699,-0.023241296,0.034616742,-0.013596029,-0.017591553,-0.0028679536,0.031124273,0.020267814,0.007821446,0.009102914,0.0147929825,0.0063013877,-0.0181966,0.016807789,0.0013735662,-0.03459501,-0.012232396,0.009856954,0.010034756,0.023922333,0.01143469,0.003737223,0.053177852,-0.0050192024,0.017508619,-0.0014785313,-0.04233918,0.05777048,-0.04016868,-0.01393735,0.020931425,-0.015165485,-0.0052575446,0.025959808,0.026864234,-0.009708917,-0.01156248,-0.0052077193,0.026623957,-0.009966706,0.0068697054,-0.00752483,0.019833652,-0.04675239,-0.03688168,-0.021523809,-0.02896387,-0.01197413,-0.022387477,-0.04929702,-0.0016422253,0.0772365,-0.012358495,-0.019077016,-0.03633127,-0.0015798162,-0.010222197,-0.03886984,0.0076833083,0.0147135295,0.044759188,0.0101098055,0.011301888,0.008772809,-0.00094311096,-0.019481545,-0.006737537,0.055845235,0.014757836,-0.015342613,0.02795337,0.0331228,0.044803847,0.01608084,0.008750878,-0.042099923,0.021947341,0.05858686,0.0043652263,-0.055612564,-0.05078902,-0.014998155,0.020209985,0.0059859077,-0.023402119,-0.0202906,0.02956925,0.04449233,-0.027513271,0.0027278617,0.027285365,0.0051843,0.06338566,-0.030163404,0.017173324,-0.04389403,0.0000047227936,0.005498994,0.01062845,0.03912123,-0.02739952,0.008175155,-0.033741094],"sampled_articles":32},"link_candidates":[{"phrase":"коллективный разум","relation":"related_topic"},{"phrase":"большинством голосов","relation":"topic"},{"phrase":"закон математики","relation":"argument"},{"phrase":"сложение нулей","relation":"argument"}],"seo_description":"Автор спорит с другом, способна ли тысяча глупцов, собравшись вместе, родить умную мысль. В тексте сталкиваются вера в коллективный разум и математический аргумент: сумма нулей даёт ноль, а большинство чаще выбирает громкого, а не лучшего. Читатель познакомится с двумя взглядами на голосование и мудрость толпы.","experience_labels":["opinion","new_perspective","explanation"],"overall_confidence":0.85}}